The life of a gay country college boy

One of our readers, Justin Sullivan, has been kind enough to share with us the story of his life thus far. I won’t call it a coming out story because I think he is still in a long, arduous journey. Best of luck to you, Justin, and thank you for your story. Here is the unedited email below, as well as Justin’s email address for anyone who wishes to contact him.


To Robert, Ben, & Brad:

It’s amazing how life will put things in our way without us expecting it. Coming across your blog has been an incredible blessing and brought a new outlook on my own life. My name is Justin Sullivan. I’m 21 years old, and I attend Mississippi State University as a Junior. I would like to tell you my own story, and how you three have inspired me to do something that I didn’t think I would do for a very long time.

I was born and bred in Mississippi with deep ties to the Baptist denomination. My great-grandfather would say in his first sermon at a new church, “I was Baptist born, Baptist bred, and when I’m gone, I’ll be Baptist dead.” In truth, he certainly was that. That of course led to the majority, if not all, my family members being raised in a Southern Baptist church and home. I was the first born of my mom and dad. My dad was the first born of his parents, and his dad was the firstborn, and then you get the picture. Even as I was being born, I would one day be expected to take upon that mantle of being the head of the Sullivan family. I was expected to marry, be successful, and produce more children. Obviously, we know how babies are born, and when I realized I was gay….well….that was going to be a problem.

Growing up, I knew something was different about myself. At a young age, I had no awareness of liking girls or boys, but even though I couldn’t name it or describe, something different was there. I could certainly feel it. It wasn’t until early puberty that “those feelings” started to set in. I was very scared. I had always heard that gays were disgusting, foul, hell bound, etc. I did my own research into homosexuality with the help of the internet. Secretly, after my family had went to bed, I would log on to the computer and absorb vast amounts of information of being gay. I found myself in chatrooms talking to people who had or were going through the same thing. For the first time ever, I realized I was not alone. Yet, that didn’t solve much for me.

I came to the conclusion it was just a phase, and I pursued, or at least attempted to pursue other things. I read my Bible each day, talked to God every moment I had. I was on such a high with God, it was incredible. However, I still felt attracted toward guys. What was wrong with me? I cried myself to sleep each night praying that God would take it away from me. I thought I had done something so wrong, and He was punishing me for it. I promised to do anything He wanted if He just took it all away from me! Nothing ever happened. I dated girls hoping it would help. Kissing a girl felt like kissing my sister — it felt so unnatural for me. After graduating high school, I was still at a point where I thought I could push the feelings of liking guys away and build a life with a woman. Sure, it would be hard, but my family expected me to have a family. I did not want to let anyone down. I could just cover it all up. This led to the first semester of my college year being terrible. I slipped into a deep depression causing me to ask my mom to sign up for counseling.

I told her that I needed to talk to someone because of anxiety issues. It is true that I have anxiety issues, while some belong to different things, such as school, family, or work, the majority of my stress came from being gay. I walked into the counselor’s office trying to figure out a convinicing story of what I would say to allow her to help me. She began to ask questions about what made me stress out. I told her the deaths of my grandparents, not having any friends at college, etc, etc. She then asked about any relationships I’ve had. Months before, I had been invovled with a guy discreetly. It didn’t last very long, and I ended it because I thought I could turn myself straight. I referred to the guy in this relationship as “they.” The counselor knew something was up. At that point, I knew I had to tell her, tell someone.

“You promise everything stays between you and me,” I asked her. She absolutely agreed it would. I took a very deep breath, looked down at the floor at my tapping foot, and paused for what seemed like eternity. “I’m gay.” Saying that aloud for the first time was a liberating experience. I had never said it aloud. I had barely said it to myself, but for the first time, I accepted my sexuality. Her response caught me off guard. “I know,” she said. She could tell I was a bit surprised, and she said that she knew when I talked about the relationship that I was referring to a guy.

I’d like to say that from this point on, it got incredibly easy, but only harder. My counselor did not recommend I tell anyone else about me just yet, until I was fully ready. In reality, I wanted to tell my mom. I was so close to her. She had always been my biggest supporter, and she is the greatest mother in the world who will go to the ends of the universe to make sure my sister and me are taken care of. All day long and to the night, I contemplated telling my mom. How would I do it? Write a letter and run away? Call her? I decided to tell her that night in our computer room. My sister and dad had went to bed, and it was the most opportune time to tell her. I had been quiet most of the evening, and she finally asked what was wrong. I asked her if she would ever be disappointed in me. She of course said no. From that point on, I knew I had to tell her. What followed was the most emotional time and talk I’ve ever had with my mom. She accepted me, and told me she would always love me.

After that, I knew I had to open my life up slowly. As the months passed, I told some of my cousins, my grandmother, my sister, and close friends. Some of my close friends took it very hard and shut me away for a long time. I was thankful when they finally came around. I’m sure you noticed that I did not tell my dad up until that point. I knew my dad would be the hardest person to tell of all people. He doesn’t understand things like what I went through. I knew I wanted to be independent of him before I told him anything, but it’s funny how things don’t always happen in our time.

I was having a conversation one night at home about being gay. Unbeknown to me, my dad was at the door listening. Was it wrong for him to eavesdrop? Of course, but it happened. When he barged in, he went crazy. I mean crazy. He started yelling, cursing, throwing things around. My sister and mom were in tears. He told me that I would never get my truck back, and he kicked me out. Fortunately, I lived near my grandmother, so I got some of my stuff and went to be with her. As the months passed, my dad called me many hurtful things. I’m ashamed to put some of them on here, because no child should hear those hurtful things from a parent.

It broke my heart to see my dad like that. For Father’s Day of last year, I wrote a letter explaining my situation to him hoping it would give him a different outlook on the situation. I think it did some good. Time does heal wounds, and I believe it did for him. Things aren’t the same still, but we have a good relationship again. We talk, not about my personal life, but we do talk. I did get my truck back. I still go back home. I still love my dad. He wrote me a letter not too long ago telling me he was proud of me, and that he loved me. I couldn’t help but bawl my eyes out as I traveled back to school. As bad as the things were that he was saying, I still had unconditional love for my dad.

This past semester in college, I was inducted into Beta Upsilon Chi Fraternity at MSU. It is a Christian fraternity on campus. No one knows about me, and it is hard. In some ways by becoming part of this fraternity, I feel I have reverted myself back to who I was before I came out to people. I have told one guy int the fraternity, and he seems fine with it; however, I know the majority of the fraternity will not feel the same way. I’ve been praying and seeking God’s help in this for a long time, and I believe he finally has given me the answer. He has led me to your website to show me that I don’t have to be ashamed of myself.

In many ways, I’m not, but there are still areas that I need to patch up. I plan to address my fraternity concerning my sexuality. It may lead to my expulsion from the fraternity and losing many brothers, but I would rather be hated for who I am than loved for what I am not. Robert, I especially know the difficulty you face here in the South. It is tough, very tough. The environment is not always good for gay guys. Many Southerners see the typical gay guy as one who runs around in high heels dressed in makeup. However, I can see from you and also myself, we are further from that image than one can be. All three of you play sports, and so far, I have not seen you wear dresses. I myself was an athlete in school and enjoyed it very much. I still enjoy going to the gym and being apart of that environment. It’s healthy for your body and mind.

So, thank you. All three of you are doing a great thing. I know there will be downs, but don’t give up. You reach an audience out there that you may never personally meet, but they are there rooting you on. I want to be there for all three of you. You all seem like great people. I hope we can live in a world where one day being gay doesn’t define us, but instead a trait we have, just like I have brown  hair.

I apologize for the very long letter, and that’s not the entirety of what has all happened, but I hope it has given some glimpse into the life of a gay country college boy.

May God Bless You All,


But the LORD said to Samuel, “Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The LORD does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart.”    1 Samuel 16:7

About Brad,Robert,Ben

We are three kids from three different time zones, with one common goal. This is our voice:
This entry was posted in Ben, Share Your Story. Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to The life of a gay country college boy

  1. Jim at Outsports says:

    Wow, Justin, that was very emotional and from your heart. All the best to you but you seem like a very self-aware person and brave.

  2. Amanda says:

    Thanks for sharing your story. I can’t imagine how difficult it must be to reconcile your religious beliefs and sexual orientation. I hope that some day you can feel safe in expressing who you really are. Who knows? Maybe your fraternity needs someone like you to open up their eyes.

  3. Theo says:

    Justin, incredible and emotional story. My thoughts are with you as you go through this.

  4. Pingback: Walk the Road Gives a Voice to Gay High-School Athletes — The Good Men Project Magazine

  5. Jhan says:

    wow. The story was great. =).

    I am glad your father and you are patching things up.

  6. Mark says:

    Amazing story. I got choked up reading it.

  7. Michael says:

    Justin – There are so many who have been touched by your story and who support you. Always remember God gave you life. God created you as you are and you must honor your gift by living your life as God intended and allowing yourself to be loved for who you are. You were not created to live your life based on other’s expectations. Always hold your head high and be true to yourself. I can also assure you God loves you as you are.

    I will pray that you find continuous strength and courage in your journey of discovery. The Christian response to those who are gay has always struck me as so contradictory to who Christ was. Reach out to those who support you! I have walked a similar path to discovery. My Mother and her family were Southern Baptist. My Dad’s family was Catholic. Courage, support, and yes faith made me a stronger man.


  8. Jeph says:

    From a State alum, believe me when I say you are very far from alone. When I came out I discovered the largest fraternity on earth waiting for me, and there are plenty of great guys out there (even in Starkvegas). So I say: Go brother dawg!

  9. Justin says:

    Thank you all for the comments! It is very inspiring to see what you have all said. And Jeph, so awesome to see another MSU bulldog!

  10. Lee Wind says:

    Wow. How great that you got this letter, and that Justin has come to the point where he really gets

    “I would rather be hated for who I am than loved for what I am not.”

    That’s a profoundly important realization, and I applaud him for it. It would be great if he could check back in and let us know how it goes with his frat. We’ll be cheering him on.

    And to Brad, Robert and Ben – this should make you feel awesome. You are making a BIG difference in the lives of others, just by being yourselves and having the courage to stand up and do this blog! Congrats!


  11. woychck AL says:

    TO all four of you guys. The courage tobe who you are and stand up . Justin I know how you feel being from a Catholic family and a father who was a career army man. I didnt have the courage at the time to talk to him when he was alive. I know how you must felt when your dad did find out and the way he reacted. I would still be the sameway towards my father also. I was forced out of the service at your guys age and lost my career and faced law inforcement when I was outed, back at that time it was not allowed and was considered a infraction seeing how it was the early 80’s.

    Be earlier being pointed out to you. God made you and gave you a beautiful gift enjoy it. DOnt let anyone put you down and love yourself and be who you are. Someday maybe you will figure out what to do with your frat bothers and maybe you can show them god made everyone different. But to remeber everyone still puts their pants on one leg at a time. Love your story and im glad Brad, Robert and Ben gave you the courage to look at yourself and go on. I apperciate all you guys cause you all make the world a much better place to live in.

    Thanks again. Woychck Al

  12. adina says:

    GREAT story!!

  13. Paul says:

    Is no one here disturbed by the fact that both Justin and Robert appear to be putting down gays that DO fit the stereotype of being effeminate dress-wearers.? That they are trying to show how they are better than them? That because they play sports they dont merit the discrimination that the effeminates face and should be accepted because they are just like straight people (well, except that they like guys?)
    I hope my perception is wrong and that someone will correct me. Everyone deserves acceptance as long as they are ethical, moral human beings, whether they are guys that wear dresses or girls that like to fix trucks.

  14. Justin says:

    Paul, as the writer of this story, I believe you can’t be further from the truth. Nowhere in my story do I discriminate or put down gays that enjoy being effeminate. I’m simply stating that it is the stereotype of most openly gay guys in society. Never once did I say I was better than anyone; therefore, I don’t appreciate you accusing me of such derogatory statements.

    You are exactly right when you say we all deserve acceptance, masculine or feminine. However, in this world today, especially in the South, the hostility comes from straight people who see gay guys as acting feminine or lesbians acting butch. There’s nothing wrong with how they live their lives. However, people also need to see that there are gay guys that act masculine and lesbians that act feminine. The dominant face of homosexuality is effeminate guys and butch girls. The other part of the homosexual group wants to show the world that there is a different side than the usual stereotype.

    Once again, everyone deserves to be treated equally. I feel, as do many others, that people also need to see there is another side to gays guys and girls they don’t normally see or hear about.

    • anton says:

      i would also hope that you might be implying that- as athleltic, all-american, boy-next-door types_ it would have been easy for you guys to ‘play it straight’ and be gay on the down low. but just because you can pass for straight doesn’t mean you should take advantage of it. i also agree that people need to know that not all gays are effeminate, limp wristed queens-

      i was wondering why you would have to tell the guys in your fraternty about your sexuality- are the straight guys announcing that they’re straight? if it doesn’t come up and it’s not an issue- why make it an issue- as a christian fraternity i imagine there won’t be many parties requiring naked girl friends. and in the course of a day- how many times does one’s sexual orientation have anything to do with the day’s activities- i would imagine the only reason the brothers would need to know is if they have social events that require you to bring your girl friend or a date_ then they’d need to know your girl friend is a boy friend. our sexual orientation is just a small part of what makes us us- if you just come out and say ‘i’m gay’ for no reason other than to announce it_ then you’re making your sexuality a big deal- an ‘in your face’ issue_ when it should just be on a ‘need to know’ basis. does the clerk who checks out your groceries need to know you’re gay- no.

  15. Amazing story and very similar to my own “coming out” story…although I came out to my family my senior year in high school, as another openly gay southerner (South Carolina..USC) I must commend you on making such a great move….I’m sure the relief of pressure and stress feels beyond rejoiceful…I know it was for myself when I made that move….Congrats to you on that and just so you know I have a large Facebook following of straight gay supporters from all over the US but mostly from right here in the good ol country South, there I speak openly as well and blog there about my life as a gay man and the things I go through living in the South as an openly gay male…(even though I just returned back home from a 8 month visit to NYC)….I am about to bring my work to WordPress as well I am there on Facebook at the moment speaking life through its many experiences…… oldest brother is a preacher and my family is deep in the church as well but they are loving and accepting to me just as your family are to you and thats remarkable…not so many of our counterparts and predecessors are as blessed and lucky as you and I….I must share your story to my Facebook family…you touched my heart and I am sure that you will touch theirs as well…thank you so much for your amazing story sir…..

  16. Zach D. Taylor says:

    Justin i know what its like to hear those things from your parent. But im glad i read it! It helped me a lot when i was depressed. Thanks a bundle XD

  17. Tom says:

    Wow Justin’s story sounds identical to my own (including the fraternity). However, my story happened 30 years ago. I have lived in a major city for the last 25 years and just assumed that the world has changed everywhere but …..I can’t believe how similar his experience is to my own. Looking back, I realize I’m someone else now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s